HSE Study Reveals Imbalance in the Generative AI Market
Researchers at HSE University analysed how effectively the global generative artificial intelligence market converts investment into real revenue, concluding that AI is currently developing faster than it is paying off. The results have been published in the journal Foresight and STI Governance.
In recent years, generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) has become one of the main areas of technological investment. Companies are pouring billions of dollars in chips, servers, and data-centre infrastructure, expecting rapid economic returns from large language models.
However, market expectations may be overstated. HSE University Academic Supervisor Yaroslav Kuzminov and Ekaterina Kruchinskaia, Associate Professor at the Faculty of Social Sciences and Senior Lecturer at the Department of Higher Mathematics, set out to assess the balance of the generative AI market and whether a gap exists between infrastructure investment and revenues from AI technologies.
The authors applied the DEA method—a model used to analyse the efficiency of complex economic systems based on multiple input and output parameters. In this case, the ‘input’ consisted of revenues of AI hardware manufacturers (chips, servers, semiconductors, and data-centre infrastructure), including companies such as AMD, Intel, and NVIDIA. The ‘output’ was the revenue of companies developing and monetising AI solutions, including Sony, OpenAI, Google DeepMind, Amazon, and Apple. In essence, the model simulates the AI market at both the input and the output stages, assuming that these players set the main agenda.
The analysis covers the period from 2016 to 2024. Importantly, the years themselves were treated as the units of analysis—although companies typically serve as units in this method. This decision was deliberate: the authors aimed to evaluate the efficiency of AI development overall in each specific year, rather than within individual companies. To test the robustness of the results, calculations were performed both in absolute terms and with adjustments for global GDP. This approach made it possible to assess the relative efficiency of the generative AI market across different years.
The analysis showed that the development of the GenAI market is nonlinear. As generative models emerged and underwent initial commercialisation between 2016 and 2021, efficiency increased. However, beginning in 2021 the trend changed: efficiency indicators declined despite a sharp rise in investment. After a short-term surge in 2023, efficiency again returned to the level recorded in 2022.
Ekaterina Kruchinskaia
‘From a purely methodological perspective, the results suggest that the AI solutions market is developing according to a catch-up model: revenues from software products do not yet compensate for the massive investment in hardware infrastructure. Increased demand for chips and computing power is driven by the development of large language models, but their commercial returns remain limited and do not offset the cost of hardware technologies or further investment in them,’ said Ekaterina Kruchinskaia.
According to the researchers, the current development model strengthens the position of hardware manufacturers but produces limited economic returns, as computing power becomes an end in itself. The market for AI solutions and applications capable of influencing social processes—for example, by increasing labour productivity—faces not only constraints such as the high cost of hardware and training runs, shortages of qualified personnel, and technological limits of the models, but also struggles to generate sufficient revenue, especially when compared with the scale of investment required.
Yaroslav Kuzminov
‘AI is indeed transforming not only the economy and companies’ business models but also everyday social life. This is evident in our daily lives. At the same time, its influence is actually spreading more slowly than it may appear and is less productive than many would like. Many people speak of a bubble in the AI market—a phenomenon not new to the global economy. It would be fair to say that such risks do exist. Our model opens the door to a more practical discussion in this direction. It is important to have not only analytical tools but also an applied plan, and a straightforward one at that. Without improving the efficiency of applied solutions, expanding their adoption and pursuing more balanced investment planning, further positive progress will be difficult,’ noted Yaroslav Kuzminov.
The authors emphasise that studies of this kind are important not only for the academic community but also for businesses, investors, and the development of balanced science and technology policy in the field of artificial intelligence.
See also:
HSE Economists Use Search Queries to Forecast Birth Rates
Researchers from the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences have shown that the accuracy of birth rate forecasts for Russia can be improved by almost 50% by incorporating the dynamics of online search queries related to pregnancy and childbirth into forecasting models. In the best-performing models, the forecasting error fell from 4.6% to 3.2%. The findings have been published in Populations and Economics.
HSE Researchers Discover Who Eats Out in Russia—And Why
Around one-third of Russians (31.3%) rarely eat out or buy ready-made meals. The core group of active consumers—those who eat out or purchase prepared food almost every day or several times a week—accounts for only about 9% of the population. These are the findings of a study conducted by the HSE Institute for Social Policy. According to the researchers eating out is no longer a marker of high social status in Russia.
Ancient Craniiform Brachiopod: A Newly Discovered Species with a Unique Shell Shape and Lifestyle
Scientists from HSE University, MSU, and Tallinn University of Technology have studied a fossil species of ancient brachiopods that lived in a warm sea in what is now northern Estonia more than 445 million years ago. These ancient brachiopods developed a cup-shaped shell with a protective 'cap' that shielded them from overgrowth by other marine organisms. The study has been published in Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology.
Scientists Develop Bacterium-Sized Microlaser
An international team of researchers, including scientists from HSE University–St Petersburg, has developed microlasers that emit deep-ultraviolet light at a wavelength of 255 nanometres. The devices operate at room temperature, and the smallest of them measures just two micrometres in diameter—roughly the size of a bacterium. These microlasers could be used in sensors, spectroscopic systems, photonic chips, and communication devices. The paper has been published in Optics & Laser Technology.
HSE Develops App for Assessing Phonological Processing in Children
Researchers at the HSE Centre for Language and Brain have developed a new digital tool for assessing children's phonological processing skills—the ZARYA (Sound Analysis of the Russian Language) test battery. It is the first standardised application in Russia designed to provide a fast and reliable assessment of children's ability to distinguish speech sounds, retain them in working memory, and perform phonemic analysis. The app runs on Android tablets and smartphones and is available for download from RuStore. Details of the test validation have been published in the Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research.
Researchers Discover How Spelling Errors Slow Down Reading in Russian
Psycholinguists from the Centre for Language and Brain at HSE University–St Petersburg have shown that words that are frequently misspelled are processed more slowly by readers, even when presented with the correct spelling. The researchers confirmed this effect for the first time using Russian-language materials and found that response speed is most strongly linked to how confidently individuals can distinguish the correct spelling of a word from an incorrect one. The study has been published in The Mental Lexicon.
Scientists Discover Why Europium 'Misbehaves'
Europium is a rare-earth metal responsible for the pure red glow in displays and other luminescent materials. For a long time, however, it refused to emit light when surrounded by certain organic molecules known as acylpyrazolone ligands. Chemists have now uncovered the reason: in europium complexes with these ligands, a 'black window' appears—a charge-transfer state in which the energy absorbed by the ligand is dissipated as heat rather than emitted as light. Understanding this mechanism opens the way to designing more efficient red-emitting materials for displays, fluorescent thermometers, and chemical sensors. The results have been published in Dalton Transactions.
HSE Economists Reveal How the Wage Gap Emerges Among Vocational School Graduates
HSE researchers examined the careers of 600,000 graduates of Russian secondary vocational education programmes and found that at the start of their careers, the gender wage gap reaches 23%, doubling after three years. This disparity is largely due to male and female students choosing different occupations when enrolling in vocational schools. These were the findings made by Sergey Roshchin, Natalya Yemelina, and Ksenia Rozhkova from of the HSE Faculty of Economic Sciences. The article has been published in Educational Studies.
HSE Researchers Make Aldehydes Perform Dual Function
Chemists from HSE University have discovered a way to carry out a reductive addition reaction without using an external reducing agent. Instead, the required 'resource' is supplied by the aldehyde itself, one of the reaction participants. This approach helps prevent unwanted side reactions, reduces toxicity, and simplifies the production and synthesis of organic molecules, including those used in the manufacture of medicines. The study has been published in Journal of Catalysis.
HSE Scientists Explain Why Findings in Autism Research Differ
Researchers from the Cognitive Health and Intelligence Centre at HSE University conducted the first-ever systematic review of studies on the specifics of emotion-from-motion perception in autism. The review showed that differences found between autistic and non-autistic individuals are largely associated with the experimental design and the types of tasks given to study participants. The review findings have been published in Research in Autism.